In a rare moment of on-air confrontation, British journalist and commentator Douglas Murray took Joe Rogan to task during a recent episode of The Joe Rogan Experience, calling out the podcast host for regularly platforming conspiracy theorists and pushing unbalanced narratives on major global issues — particularly the Israel-Hamas conflict.

The exchange, which quickly gained traction online, saw Murray question Rogan’s pattern of inviting controversial voices like Ian Carroll, who once compared vaccine mandates to the Holocaust, and Darryl Cooper, known for painting Winston Churchill as the villain of World War II. Murray challenged Rogan on the wisdom of giving such figures significant airtime without also bringing on credible voices from the opposing side.

“You’ve had a lot of anti-Israel voices on here. People like Dave Smith, who hasn’t even visited the region, yet talks endlessly about Gaza and Israel,” Murray said, underscoring what he sees as a dangerous pattern of one-sided coverage.

Rogan, who has long defended his eclectic guest list as a platform for free expression, appeared slightly taken aback by the pushback but remained open to the discussion. Still, Murray pressed further, noting that Rogan had yet to host prominent defenders of Israel or Ukraine in the same manner.

“You’ve never even had me on here without someone like Dave Smith as a counterweight,” Murray pointed out.

Smith, a libertarian comedian and frequent Rogan guest, was present during the exchange and defended the inclusion of controversial voices, arguing that Rogan’s long-form style allows for ideas to be fully explored. But Murray pushed back hard, accusing Smith of “running his mouth about Gaza” for over a year without firsthand experience or geopolitical expertise.

Critics of Rogan’s show have long voiced concerns about the potential influence of misinformation and conspiratorial rhetoric given the podcast’s massive reach. Murray’s direct challenge may have marked a turning point in that ongoing debate — forcing Rogan to reckon with the role his platform plays in shaping public opinion, especially during times of war and political instability.

As the episode circulated online, many praised Murray for standing his ground and pushing for more responsible discourse on one of the world’s most influential podcasts.